The Dare

Erica and Bryn did that together, too - but only Bryn made it back to the surface. Eighteen months later, Bryn's family drags her to Crescent City to make a fresh start. At first Bryn is able to bury Erica's memory and her own guilty conscience in a town where no one knows her past. But when a Twitter post from "EricaNShaw" pops up on Bryn's wall and a chilling voicemail appears on her phone, she realizes that her past - and her darkest memory - has come back for revenge.