Whose History? The Struggle for National Standards in American Classrooms

In the 1990s the debate over what historyand more importantly whose historyshould be taught in American schools resonated through the halls of Congress, the national press, and the nations schools. Politicians such as Lynne Cheney, Newt Gingrich, and Senator Slade Gorton, and pundits such as Rush Limbaugh, John Leo, and Charles Krauthammer fiercely denounced the findings of the National Standards for History, which subsequently became a major battleground in the nations ongoing struggle to define its historical identity. To help us understand what happened, Linda Symcox traces the genealogy of the National History Standards Project from its origins as a neo-conservative reform movement to the drafting of the Standards, through the 18 months of controversy and the debate that ensued, and the aftermath. Broad in scope, this case study includes debates on social history, world history, multiculturalism, established canons, national identity, cultural history, and liberal education. Symcox brilliantly illuminates the larger issue of how educational policy is made and contested in the United States, revealing how a debate about our childrens education actually became a struggle between competing political forces.